The Middleweight Championship was a midcard title held by several prominent members of the NAFW roster.

Christian
August 30, 2002 - October 25, 2002
57 days
Championship Reinstated - Awarded to last European Champion
Championship Retired

Sabu
June 29, 2001 - July 29, 2001
31 days
Championship Retired - Sabu leaves NAFW due to match stipulation

The Intruder
June 21, 2001 - June 29, 2001
9 days

Ripcord
June 15, 2001 - June 21, 2001
7 days

Spaz
June 15, 2001 - June 15, 2001
1 day

Ripcord
June 1, 2001 - June 15, 2001
15 days

Amazon
May 4, 2001 - June 1, 2001
29 days

Griever
April 13, 2001 - May 4, 2001
22 days
Wins 5-Way Elimination Match to become Champion