The following is the All-Time Roster of the NAFW, spanning nearly 8 years. Hundreds upon hundreds of wrestlers have passed through the Foundation whether it was known as Fantasy Wrestling, New Age Fantasy Wrestling, the North Atlantic Foundation of Wrestling, or the North American Foundation of Wrestling. The following wrestlers were around long enough to maybe have more than a cup of coffee during their run in the NAFW. Some are even NAFW legends! Wrestlers are listed alphabetically by the first letter of the name or nickname they were most recognized under. If the wrestler was most notably a tag team wrestler, he or she will be listed under that tag team's name.

# - A - B - C - D - E - F - G - H - I - J - K - L - M
N - O - P - Q - R - S - T - U - V - W - X - Y - Z

#
2Guys - Jackle & Menace

A
Adrian Veritak
Ainsley Lake
AiR
Amazon
Andy D
Angels of Death - Aaron Worth / Id (II) & Jim Crimz
Arwel Jones
Ashley Collier
The Asylum - Mystic & Toilet Duck w/ Decent B & Grandma Thorpe

B
"Karnage" Ben Hurst
Ben Jackman
Billy the Kid
Brick and Mortar - John Brick & Casey Mortar
Buddy Harbor with Martin Harbor

C
Caesar
Charles "Tharodund" Johnson
Children of the Grave - Vito Marciano & Marius Mavado
"The Gift" Chris Match
"Classy" Chris Parys
"Primetime" Chris Sanders
Chronic
Clive Dangerfield
Collin Braddock III
"Crazy Boy" Tyrone Smith
Cruel Intentions - Derrick Shaw & Matt Steele with John E. Styles
Crystal Vassall

D
Dan Stein
"The Word" David Kurresh / Driver
David "Kaos" Wagner
David Graves
The Dehmer Twins - Geoffrey Dehmer & Nathan Dehmer
"Demonfire" / "The Demon" Kevin Hyatt
Derek Clarke
Diablo LoKo
Diamond Del Carver
Dwayne Bishop

E
Eros Mako

F
The Fabulous Cosmo
Faithless / Sorrow
Far 'n' Wide - Masato Kabashi Ten & The Zoid
Fox Strife
Frankie the Hamster
The Frat Pack - The Chuggernaut & Maggot

G
The Goods - Slush & Ammo
Gordon Edward / Drew Dog Daron
Grey Goose - Timothy Grey & Christopher Goose
"Griever" Tyler Hyatt

H
Harley Davidson - Jack Harley & Jim Davidson
Harris and Clark - Ken Harris & Troy Clark
Hawk
Heatwave with Nicole Burbank
Henderson and Mandell - Fox Henderson & Barry Mandell
Hush with Aleister Essex

I
"The Intruder" Matthew Kurresh

J
Jack "The Chopper" Flint
Jaime Alejandro
Jake Walker
Jester Smiles
Joanie Lee
Johnny Cruelty
Johnny Malibu
JTC
"The Judge" James Batty
The Justice League / The Sensations - Sean Summers & Steve Summers
Justin Credible

K
Keith Owens with Melissa Hayes
Kid Gangster
Krystian
Kyle Cole

L
Sauve "Le Poncho" Descartes
Lorenzo Richards

M
Mad Dawg
Mark Dangerfield
The Maxx
The Mexican Toiletries - Señor Bag of Crap & El Asso Wipo
"The Farmer" Michael Fitzpatrick-McCarthy
"Creeping Death" Mike Castleberry
Mike Lane
Mike Stryker

N
Nathan Boswell
Nefarious
Nightmare

O
Old School Empire - Dustin Thomas & "The Alpha" Shane Thomas
Olin Clay

P
The Party Animal
Paul Colard
Peter Gilmour
Phases of Destruction - Rook, the Angel of Mercy & Cylent
The Popular Kids - Timmy, Tommy, and Tire Swing
The Pretty Boys - Brad Jobs & Barry Worzt
The Prophet
"Psycho" Tommy Smith with Carlos Smith

R
Rage & Chaos
Raven / Randy Peacock
"The Reaper" Leonard Aarons with Vanessa Chamberlain
"The Canadian Dragon" Ripcord
Rise - Christian & Re-N4-cer
Rob Feature
The Rock 'n' Rex Express - Scott Rocker & Rex Michaels with Gillian Narcotia Ruiz
"Ravishing" Ron Barker

S
Sean "Spaz" Thomas / The Seer with Twitch
Sebastian Hawke
The Sickest - Jeremy "Zodiac Cyborg" "Diamond" Lewis & Synn
Snake with Wilson
Alex "Snyper" Kien
Social Disorder - Boss & The Great Speez
Stud Muffan & V.C.R.

T
T-Bird
teh l33t - Rurik Krychek & Dave Richmond
Thomas Fitzgerald / Mr. USA with Vanessa Hamm
Ti-Core
Tommy Fish & Toby Fish
TomWorth / The Apostle / Id (I) with Jake Walker
Toothache
Trevor Cunning

V
Vin Yun Chang / El Pollo Diabolico
Vinsanity

W
Whitney Sarven
The Widowmaker
Wraith

X
X² - XL & XXXXL
Xavier Caine
X-Cold

Y
Youth at Large - Ryan Cardinal / Evil Sean Thomas & JaZon King

Z
Zangief